Walmart is owned by the Walton family, worth around $130 billion. (Image: Mike Mozart, Flickr)
The coronavirus pandemic is laying bare the perils that come with millions of workers in the U.S. lacking paid sick leave.
Many of these workers are employed by some of the nation’s biggest retail, grocery, fast food, and hospitality corporations, which annually rake in billions in profits. For years, workers and organizers from these industries have been sounding the alarm about the public health reasons we need paid sick time for everyone – let alone that paid sick leave is part of the “complete wage” that all workers deserve as a right.
Now, with the desperate need to contain the coronavirus, many voices are loudly proclaiming the need, right now, to offer paid sick leave to all workers.
For example, the New York Times ran an editorial on March 14th declaring that, now, “the public interest requires employers to abandon their longstanding resistance to paid sick leave.” It reads:
As the new coronavirus spreads across the United States, the time has come for restaurants, retailers and other industries that rely on low-wage labor to abandon their parsimonious resistance to paid sick leave. Companies that do not pay sick workers to stay home are endangering their workers, their customers and the health of the broader public.
Using data from the Shift Project, the NYT editorial mapped out the millions of workers, by company, who lack paid sick leave:
Corporations should pay workers to stay home when they are sick. And consumers can encourage them to do so by staying away from companies that don’t offer paid sick leave. https://t.co/GLMNrB6M3V— New York Times Opinion (@nytopinion) March 17, 2020
Here, we profile a few of the corporations that for too long have denied their workers paid sick leave even as they raked in billions in profits. Their owners and CEOs hoard money that could go towards paying the wages of sick workers and instead use this to buy expensive mansions and private planes, and maintain their status as some of the wealthiest people in the world.
Many companies, including some we discuss below, in the face of tremendous pressure, have instituted temporary paid sick leave policies tied solely to the coronavirus. But out of this crisis, paid sick leave for all should become the new and permanent norm – and to make this happen, these are some of the influential companies and billionaires who will need to be challenged.
Walmart & the retail industry
As a contrast, it’s worth highlighting the sheer wealth of Walmart’s owners. The Waltons are the richest family in the U.S., worth $130 billion.
To put this in perspective: if you took half the Walton’s wealth – $65 billion – they’d still be one of the top 5 richest families in the world.
The other $65 billion? Every one of Walmart’s 1.5 million U.S. employees could receive over $43,000.
Because it pays its workers poverty wages, Walmart has been an enormous beneficiary of backdoor subsidies in the form of assistance to its underpaid workers so they can reproduce themselves to labor another day at Walmart. In 2014, example, one report estimated that Walmart received around $6.2 billion in subsidies in the form of food stamps, health care, and other government programs.
And what’s happened when Walmart’s workers have tried to better their lives through collective bargaining? Walmart is a notorious union buster, allegedly shutting down entire stores to crush labor activism.
What Walmart does matters for everyone else. It is the iconic trendsetter of corporate retail in an era of logistics, warehouses, and global supply chains.
Like other corporations, Walmart did finally announce an ad hoc policy of paid sick leave for employees who become infected with the coronavirus or who face quarantine. Workers who don’t want to work out of fear of catching or transmitting coronavirus can stay home – but they won’t be paid.
Walmart is the biggest retail and supermarket employer that lacks paid sick leave for many workers, but far from the only one. Others include Kroger (with an estimated 189,000 workers without paid sick leave), Target (151,000), Dollar General (109,000), and Publix (89,000).
According to OpenSecrets.org, Walmart has spent at least $23,722,760 in federal elections since 1990 and $92,645,000 in federal lobbying since 1998.
Wendy’s & the fast food Industry
Fastfood megachain Wendy’s has an estimated 133,000 workers without paid sick leave.
The top owner of Wendy’s is Trian Partners, a hedge fund led by billionaire Nelson Peltz. Trian oversees $10.9 billion in assets. Peltz is worth $1.6 billion.
Wendy’s is one of Trian’s signature portfolio companies. Peltz and Trian dominate the board of Wendy’s – Peltz is Wendy’s board chair, Trian President Peter May is vice chairman, and Peltz’s son Matthew, a Trian Partner, is a board member.
Peltz lives a luxurious life. He owns a Palm Beach oceanfront estate worth an astounding $136.4 million, making it one of the most expensive residential properties in the entire country.
The value of Peltz’s estate alone could cover over $1,000 to every Wendy’s worker without paid sick leave.
Meanwhile, Wendy’s CEO Todd Penegor raked in over $16 million between 2016 and 2018.
Wendy’s is not the only fast food chain that doesn’t offer paid sick leave to workers. Others include McDonald’s (517,000), Subway (180,000), Burger King (165,000), Pizza Hut (156,000), Taco Bell (124,000), Sonic (92,000), Chick-fil-A (89,000), KFC (69,000), and others.
On March 19, Wendy’s finally announced a temporary coronavirus-related paid sick leave policy. McDonalds is also offering 14 paid sick days to employees who require quarantine, though this only applies to corporate stores, not its franchises, which make up 90% of its stores worldwide.
The fastfood industry lobbyists, such as the National Restaurant Association, have a long history of lobbying against paid sick leave legislation.
Meanwhile, the Fight for 15 campaign is highlighting the desperate need for paid sick leave in light of the coronavirus, while the New York Times posted a video, viewed by millions, of a shift manager from a Kansas City, Missouri McDonald’s who discusses the incredible stresses that come with a lack of paid sick leave.
Florida fast-food workers are on strike, but doing it from home today instead of a big rally. Workers like us need paid sick leave, whether it’s a #coronavirus pandemic or simply having to take a family member to the doctor. #FightFor15 #UnionsForAll pic.twitter.com/0qXVWuOznk— Fight For 15 (@fightfor15) March 12, 2020
According to OpenSecrets.org, Wendy’s has spent at least $4,019,409 in federal elections since 1990 and $653,500 in federal lobbying since 2007.
Starbucks & coffee megachains
While millions of customers get caffeinated at Starbucks everyday, tens of thousands of its employees regularly lack paid sick leave.
Moreover, just last year, Starbucks was forced to pay $176,000 in restitution to New York City employees for illegally requiring workers to find replacements when they needed to use sick leave.
Gaby Del Valle of Vox.com also reported on March 16:
A former Starbucks employee, who worked as a shift supervisor until last week, said management didn’t always adhere to the company’s sick-leave policies. “In practice, through the several stores I worked at, I encountered a prevailing culture [that] discouraged taking sick time,” he said. “During my last few months, before coronavirus hit, there were numerous instances where employees would come into work visibly sick, afraid of calling out because they believed management and other staff wouldn’t support them.”
Starbucks former CEO Howard Schultz, who briefly entertained a 2020 presidential run, is worth $3.24 billion as of March 24. Schultz also co-founded Maveron Capital, a venture capital firm.
Starbucks workers took it upon themselves to organize for their own safety against the coronavirus. They created a petition created to temporarily close the company’s stores in the face of the pandemic, which received over 37,000 signatures.
In a petition with over 25K signatures, Starbucks employees are calling for the company to “suspend all business hours, at every location, while continuing to pay hourly and salary workers, during the spread of the coronavirus.”https://t.co/V11DSpyMml— New York Daily News (@NYDailyNews) March 20, 2020
The petition declared: “Starbucks should suspend all business hours, at every location, while continuing to pay hourly and salary workers, during the spread of the coronavirus.”
Days later, Starbucks announced that it was closing all its cafes and only keeping its drive-thrus open. It also announced that all workers would be paid for the next 30 days, even if they don’t go to work.
But other attempts by Starbucks workers to better their own lives have been met by intense hostility from management.
Howard Schultz has been a notorious union buster. Terri Gerstein, Director of the State and Local Enforcement Project at the Harvard Law School Labor and Worklife Program, wrote last year:
For one, during Schultz’s long tenure as CEO, Starbucks repeatedly fought against workers’ attempts to organize a union. In 2008, for example, a National Labor Relations Board judge found that the company had illegally fired three workers for their union activities, as well as violated other aspects of the law. Starbucks workers in our country still don’t have a union.
Just last month, a Starbucks worker at a store in the Orlando airport was fired for trying to organize his fellow workers into a union with UNITE HERE.
According to OpenSecrets.org, Starbucks has spent at least $1,364,482 in federal elections since 1994 and $11,218,000 in federal lobbying since 1994.
Marriott International & the hotel industry
Marriott’s CEO Arne Sorenson has been in his position since 2012, previously serving as the company’s President and COO. He’s the company’s first CEO outside of the Marriott family.
Sorenson was previously a member of the board of directors of Walmart, a company, like Marriott, that is notorious for leaving its workers without basic protections. Sorenson raked in hundreds of thousands of dollars as a Wamart director. He also serves on the board of the Brookings Institute.
As Marriott’s CEO, Sorenson raked in almost $40 million in total compensation between 2016 and 2018 alone and is likely worth well beyond that. While Marriott has suspended or cut his and other senior executives’ salaries for the rest of 2020 due to the coronavirus, this will hardly make a dent in Sorenson’s net wealth.
In the midst of the current global pandemic, Marriott has ignored the safety of its workers by, as of March 25, failing to provide paid sick leave. Last week the company announced that it would be furloughing tens of thousands of workers around the world, leaving them without pay. Meanwhile, hotel and travel industry lobbying groups, and hotel CEOs that included the CEOs of Marriott and Hilton, met with the White House last week to ask for $250 billion in bailouts to the industry.
UNITE HERE , which represents many hospitality workers across the nation and has fought for paid sick leave for their Marriott workers, has said that they might dip into union strike funds to assist laid off and sick workers who need assistance. Not all Marriott workers are unionized, leaving many without support as this crisis continues.
Marriott’s anti-worker antics are nothing new. In 2018, nearly 8,000 Marriott employees in eight cities represented by UNITE HERE had to resort to a strike in frustration over stalled bargaining with the company over higher wages and greater safety measures for employees.
According to OpenSecrets.org Marriott International has spent $18,655,000 on federal lobbying since 1999 and $8,656,144 on federal campaigns since 1990.
Whole Foods & grocery chains
Whole Foods, purchased by e-commerce giant Amazon in 2017, fails to provide paid sick leave to an estimated 30,000 workers, according to the Shift Project
Grocery store employees have become front-line workers in the face of the COVID-19 pandemic in the US. Workers at Whole Foods and other grocery workers have been expressing their frustrations with the way that industry leaders are handling the crisis as stores are flooded with shoppers trying to secure provisions for shelter in place measures.
Grocery chains have historically fought against paid sick leave legislation and now have large swaths of the U.S. workforce at the forefront of the crisis without essential benefits and protections. Kroger grocery chain has over 189,000 workers working without paid sick leave, Publix chain has another 89,000, Meijers has 57,000, and Wegmans has 43,000, according to the Shift Project – though some of these chains, including Whole Foods, have enacted temporary paid sick leave policies only tied to the coronavirus.
Recently, Whole Foods has offered their employees a $2/hour pay increase through April, which doesn’t even meet the federal labor relations provisions for a 25% wage increase for employees working under hazardous conditions. And Whole Foods still provides no paid sick leave to employees unless they are diagnosed with COVID-19. Instead, the company is encouraging employees to “donate” their paid sick days to employees who need it.
Whole Foods CEO suggests employees who are not sick “donate” their vacation time to employees who are sick: https://t.co/Aw2gUqEpCD— Jason Koebler (@jason_koebler) March 13, 2020
This all comes after Whole Foods announced that they would be cutting medical benefits for part-time workers in September 2019.
And in 2018 Whole Foods sent store managers how-to videos on discouraging employees from unionizing.
According to OpenSecrets.org, Amazon has spent $20,857,113 on elections since 1998 and $91,497,031 on lobbying since 2000.
Towards paid sick leave for all workers – permanently
Workers, many already on the edge of despair and living paycheck-to-paycheck, are being hit incredibly hard by this crisis and pushed deeper into a state of precarity. Eighteen percent of workers report having lost jobs or hours since the crisis began. The president of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis President James Bullard is predicting the U.S. unemployment could hit 30% later this year.
At the same time, as Mindy Isser writes, this crisis is also becoming a moment for new gains by workers and their communities, often through them exerting their own power.
New York City teachers forced Mayor De Blasio to shut down city schools by threatening a sick-out. Autoworkers have taken wildcat actions to shut down plant production. Thousands of people signed a petition organized by Philadelphia library workers to close the city’s libraries, with paid leave for employees. Organizers across the U.S., from California to Massachusetts, have won victories to suspend evictions and utilities shut-offs.
Labor Notes reporter Dan DiMaggio has also surveyed how a range of workers – from daycare workers in Oregon to hospitality workers in New Orleans – have fought for sick pay.
As big businesses and Wall Street firms call for corporate bailouts and try to find ways to profit off of this crisis, many will be pushing in another direction: organize and build workers’ power so that this period of collective sacrifice can become a springboard to advance workers’ rights and remake our social safety.
*Update: Since the publication of this article, the Starbucks Global Corporate PR office reached out to say that “all employees have access to paid leave, including sick leave, parental leave, and family leave.” Independent research from the UC Berkeley Shift Project, featured in a March 14, New York Times editorial, estimates that 68,000 Starbucks workers say they lack access to paid sick leave. Starbucks claims this finding is inaccurate.
Correction: This article originally stated that Howard Schultz was CEO of Starbucks. Schultz is the company’s former CEO, leaving the position in 2017, and today serves as Chairman Emeritus of the Starbucks board of directors. As of last year, he remained Starbucks’ largest individual shareholder. Kevin Johnson is currently the CEO of Starbucks.